The Hotel Business Federation of Mallorca (FEHM) has issued an accusation against the Holiday rental platforms for allowing the proliferation of the illegal Offer. This accusation coincides with the opinion of the Balearic Federation d’Habitatges Turístics (FEHBATUR) in relation to the new European regulation on short-term rentals, whose approval is expected before the end of the year. Both organizations believe that this regulation will not be the definitive solution to the problem.
The European regulation aims to establish a system of data collection and sharing that is simple and harmonised in all countries of the European Union, in order to increase transparency in the Holiday rental sector.
María Frontera, president of the FEHM, emphasizes that although the regulation represents a step forward, it will not completely solve the problem of the illegal Offer. To address this problem effectively, Frontera argues that it is necessary to strengthen control from the Consell de Mallorca.
In the context of a debate on the social sustainability of Tourism in Palma, Frontera emphasizes that the problem lies not in Tourism itself, but in the increasing proliferation of the illegal Offer. According to Frontera, Holiday rental platforms, despite their investments in technology and marketing, are not complying with licensing verification and are unwilling to take responsibility in this regard. Instead of complying with the law, these platforms are focused on their businesses, which has led to a situation where virtually any Property becomes a Accommodation.
Border also points out that the problem has become so complex that today’s infrastructure cannot cope with the growing illegal Offer. The FEHM advocates taking additional measures to democratize activity in the tourism property sector and ensure an appropriate balance between the legal and illegal Offers.
Maria Gibert, manager of the Balearic Federation d’Habitatges Turístics (FEBHATUR), advocates for the democratization of Tourism and argues that everyone can have a place in the tourism sector. In their opinion, hoteliers, accustomed to hoarding the entire market, perceive the tourist property as a threat. Gibert also stresses the need to calm the debate on this issue, stressing that the ban on the tourist rental in Palma for the past six years has not had a significant impact on the reduction of rental prices or the increase of the residential Property park.
In the last ten years, data from the Hotel Business Federation of Mallorca indicate that the Offer of Legal Tourist Property has increased almost 30 times more than the Availability of hotel spaces, which has only grown by 7% in the Balearic Islands Islands. According to Gibert, this increase in the tourist property is not causing the shortage of residential Property, but rather a diversion of residential Properties to the tourist market, which makes it difficult to access the Property.
The manager of FEBHATUR praises the European initiative to harmonize data collection to improve transparency in the Holiday rental, although she believes that its implementation will be complicated. He points out that, if it is already a challenge to eradicate the illegal Offer in the Balearic Islands, it will be even more complicated through European bodies distant from citizens, especially when it comes to foreign nationals who have second homes in the region and do not use conventional commercial channels to rent. He suggests that crossing data with tax authorities could be an effective solution.
Gibert argues that the big Holiday rental platforms should not be demonized and stresses the importance of their collaboration, but also stresses that blaming them for all problems is not the solution. In addition, it praises the work of the Consell de Mallorca, the institution responsible for pursuing the illegal Offer in this area, and considers that they are doing what they can with the available resources. In his words, “The problem of coexistence between tourists and residents is not caused by Tourism, but by the Offer of illegal rental.”