The TSJIB overthrows the ban adopted by the Ajuntament de Palma considering that it is a disproportionate and unnecessary measure.
The prohibition of the tourist rental in the flats of Palma is illegal. The High Court of Justice of the Balearic Islands (TSJIB) has issued a judgment authorising this activity and says that the prohibition violates European directives, state legislation itself and is disproportionate and unnecessary.
The Association of Seasonal Rental Apartments and Properties (HABTUR) filed an appeal against the prohibition approved by the City Council and the Court agrees. The judgment says that the absolute prohibition of the Holiday rental in flats “does not appear as weighted for the purposes alleged by the City Council”.
Less radical means
It ensures that Cort “can make use of its powers, including the regulation aimed at regulating a framework for the management of economic activities that have an impact on such areas of general interest”.
“The public purposes pursued can be obtained through less radical means, some of them already positivized. The prohibition, of course, is the last of the possible solutions to the noci effects
The association that filed the appeal against Cort’s decision argues that, with this measure, it was benefiting the hoteliers. The judgment states that there is no indication that the City Council “has wanted the defendant administration to avoid and address,” the ruling adds. The judges consider that the free exercise of tourism activity “must be combined with the interests of benefiting the hotel industry by prohibiting the Holiday rental in multi-family buildings”. The ruling adds that the decision was taken on the grounds of “singular circumstances of protection of the environment and the urban environment”.
“Any intervention should be taken administrative decisions which must be proportionate, appropriate and necessary for the community”.
The Association concerned pointed out that the decision of the City of Palma violated free competition, violated the freedom to provide services and discriminated against Owners of this type of Property. Cort, for his part, argued that the prohibition tended to a protective and guarantee end of civility, the environment and even access to the Property, “but this lawying purpose must be proportionate and necessary, that is, it must be justified that the commercialization of tourist stays has economic effects, but, for the above, it is not economic planning that motivates the regulation, but the territorial planning of the Offer according to the urban, demographic conditions” They therefore reject that the prohibition was adopted for economic purposes only.
Source: UltimaHora.es