The regulation of the regime applicable to the rentals of Properties for Tourist Accommodations has continued to be the subject of complaints during 2017, according to the annual report of the Ombudsman, who has received claims from Owners who “consider having seen the freedom derived from the absence of any rule and violated their right to Property” by the regulation applied in several autonomous communities.
In recent years there has been an expansion of seasonal tourist rentals, which have experienced a significant increase due to the lack of any regulatory framework and the ease of Offering this type of Accommodations through web pages, he says in his annual management report.
The emerging rules have come to face situations that were already beginning to consolidate, which makes tourist rentals “a regulatory sector prone to conflict and complaints,” says the Ombudsman, Francisco Fernández Marugán.
The type of complaints received in this area is varied and ranges from the requirements for the exercise of this activity to the changes undertaken in the most recent reforms through the empowerment of the communities of Owners to prohibit this activity.
The regulatory scope of this activity is in the hands of the autonomous communities that have assumed competence in their statutes in the field of Tourism, once it was excluded from the Law of Urban Leases.
An “acceptable balance”
The institution recalls that in the regulation of the tourist use of Propertys the legitimate interests of the Owners to obtain an economic profitability for their Property, but also other rights and interests equally worthy of protection, such as urban, environmental management or the right to personal or family privacy of the rest of the residents of the property.
Therefore, it considers that the legislator has to find “an acceptable balance” between respecting “the liberalizing framework of the service activities imposed by European regulations and the need to adequately protect other goods and interests worthy of protection for their undoubted social value, which are also affected by this activity, such as “the environment, urbanism, the right to property, the safety of people or the obligation to contribute to the maintenance of public expenditures”.
Place ceiling and zoning
In the case of Balearic Islands, the recent reform of the tourist regulations, approved by Law 6/2017, of July 31, and complemented by Decree-Law 3/2017, of August 4, has already received the first complaints of Owners affected by a reform that aims to face the price of the Property Prices for habitual residents, as well as tourist lasaturation in certain areas and to solve the problems of coexistence of residents of multifamily properties.
The reform limits the freedom that Property Owners in Balearic Islands had been enjoying when renting them to tourists advertising them on websites of this type of establishments, says the Ombudsman, and raises the sanctions. “It was an illegal activity and the new regulation is causing the disagreement of individuals,” he adds.
“The new law opens the possibility for the Administration to control this activity through the establishment of a maximum ceiling of tourist places or the delimitation of areas suitable for tourist marketing, whose implementation is deferred to the approval of the corresponding instruments of intervention and whose suitability and proportionality may be evaluated by the Ombudsman,” he says.
Communities of Owners
Another reason for complaint is the empowerment of the communities of Owners to prohibit this activity, a provision that for the Ombudsman does not constitute a violation of the right of Property since this right is not unlimited, but is modulated or conditioned by the rules established in each case by the law and the communities of Owners.
In this sense, the Ombudsman points out that the Tourist rental affects the rights to the personal and family privacy of the rest of the residents, and their safety; all of them property and rights worthy of protection. In any case, it remains attentive to how this regulation will develop and the problems they may pose.
Source: Diario de Mallorca