If we make an Analysis of the last reform of the Law of Urban Leases, tourist leases are excluded from the application of this as long as they comply with certain requirements.
Preamble of the LAU, in recent years there has been an increasingly significant increase in the use of private Accommodation for Tourism, which could be covering situations of intrusion and unfair competition, which go against the quality of tourist destinations; hence the reform of the proposed Law excludes them specifically so that they are regulated by the regional regulations or, failing that, the regime of leases is applied.
The specific precept excludes the temporary transfer of use of a property furnished and equipped in conditions of immediate use, marketed or promoted in tourist Offer channels and carried out for profit, when it is subject to a specific regime, derived from its sectoral regulations.
That is, in order for the LAU not to be applied, these requirements must be met:
Temporary assignment of use of the entirety of a property furnished and equipped in conditions of immediate use.
Marketed or promoted in Tourist Offer channels.
Lucrative purpose.
Specific legal regime, derived from its sectoral regulations.
What should be understood by each of these requirements? The Law is silent, does not define these requirements whose concurrence determines the exclusion of their application.
The second requirement is the one that raises the greatest doubts. What does it mean to be marketed or promoted in Tourist Offer channels? Would advertising on a website be enough? The Law does not say what is meant by “marketed or promoted in tourist Offer channels”, which leads to an absolute lack of legal concreteness.
TOURIST LEASE CONTRACTS
The CAIB under the Tourism Law (Law 8/2012) allows the marketing of short tourist stays (not more than two months) of isolated or paired single-family property.
Specifically, it allows to market the use of Propertys to those people who, having the layout and configuration of a single-family property isolated or paired, in principle designed for residential use, provide tourist accommodation services that alternates with the own and residential use that the Property has in certain conditions.
* These tourist services to be provided, directly or indirectly, are:
Periodic cleaning of the property.
Bed linen, lingerie, houseware in general and replacement of
these. Maintenance of the facilities.
Service to the public during business hours.
24-hour telephone support services.
The Autonomous Law clearly speaks of the marketing of tourist stays and expressly indicates that it will be understood that there is marketing of tourist stays in Properties when it can not be proven, in accordance with the applicable regulations, that the contracting carried out is in accordance with the legislation on urban, rustic or other special laws.
Is it possible to market the use of properties that are not isolated or paired single-family? No, the Balearic Law considers a serious infringement the Offer or marketing of tourist stays in Properties that do not meet the established requirements or conditions, among which it is, that it is a single-family or isolated Property. This serious infringement is punishable by a fine of 4,001 to €40,000.
Consequently, the Balearic Islands
By relating the above to the Balearic regional regulations with the exclusion that is operated through the LAU we reach the following conclusions:
– With regard to private Accommodations for Tourism, the LAU refers to the Balearic Islands Tourism Act Islands whenever it is:
Temporary assignment of use of the entirety of a property furnished and equipped in conditions of immediate use.
Marketed or promoted in Tourist Offer channels.
Lucrative purpose.
– The Balearic Tourism Law Islands allows the marketing of stays
tourists in single-family properties isolated or paired and prohibits it in the other Properties, punishing it with a fine.
At this point, we must differentiate the use of private accommodations for Tourism from seasonal leases. The first excluded from the LAU provided that the requirements (indeterminate) that we have mentioned, to which the Balearic Tourism Law will apply will be applied (prohibition with respect to those Properties that are not isolated or paired single-family). The second, seasonal leases, which will continue to be applied by the LAU.
As we have mentioned, the regime of seasonal leases has not been modified. What is meant by seasonal lease?
The LAU says that it is understood by lease for use other than that of Property that, falling on a building, has as its primary destination one different from that of satisfying the permanent need of Property of the tenant; in particular, this consideration will be the leases of urban farms held by season, whether this summer or any other.
From a theoretical point of view, in order to differentiate the tourist lease from the seasonal lease, we can define them as follows:
The tourist lease implies a marketing (habituality) of tourist stays, which means registering in this activity; lease that requires, in addition to the Accommodation, the provision of certain complementary services.
The seasonal lease is not a marketing, but a temporary assignment, without any additional obligation (no services must be provided). This lease will be governed by what the contractors freely agree.
As conclusions, we can state the following:
Lack of legal certainty: the requirements to understand are not defined
excluded from the LAU to tourist leases.
Balearic Tourism Law Islands, unlike other laws
regional, only allows the commercialization of tourist stays in
Single-family properties isolated or paired. Prohibit the others.
Under the protection of the LAU, the seasonal lease may fall on any building and will not include the provision of the complementary services referred to in the Balearic Islands Tourism Law (Law 8/2012 of 19 July).
IMPACT OF STATE MARKET UNIT REGULATIONS.
Irene Perelló, manager of ApturBalearic Islands, defended the work of the National Commission on Markets and Competition (CNMC). This body, which belongs to the Ministry of Economy, supervises the content of the rules published by the different Administrations for an improvement of the quality of the regulation.
The CNMC is very clear about its position that it is none other than to defend “any restriction imposed by the Administration for the access or exercise of economic activity must be necessary, the protection of some imperative reason of general interest of those contained in article 3.11 of Law 17/2009 of November 23” must be directed according to the provisions of article 5 of the Law of Guarantee of Market Unity.
The design of a standard should allow for effective implementation. So, an effective regulatory framework is therefore one that allows the achievement of the objectives it pursues. Otherwise, burdens may be being imposed on companies and accepting restrictions on competition to achieve certain objectives whose achievement, however, can be frustrated by a lack of effectiveness of the standard.
There are many factors that affect the effectiveness of the standard, including:
A clear definition of the objectives it aims to achieve. . If it is not clear what is intended with a certain regulatory intervention, the design of the standard will hardly be logical and adequate.
These purposes should be easily enforceable. A standard whose compliance or monitoring is complex and expensive can become ineffective because neither administration nor administered are able to comply properly, while still imposing costs on both.
Administrations must work in coordination. A lack of coordination of the different administrations can unnecessarily complicate the regulatory framework in which the activity of companies unfolds.
Avoid legal loopholes. An effective design requires that regulatory developments are not delayed and that they are known in advance what their master lines will be. In short, the regulatory framework in sectors that are intended to open up to competition should be analysed and prepared ex ante in the most concrete way possible.
To this end, the CNMC uses three principles to take into account:
Principle of necessity. There must be a normative vacuum or inequality that motivates the legislator to draft a rule.
Principle of proportionality. The development of any standard must clearly define its objectives. These goals should be proportionate to the public interest they wish to protect.
Principle of minimum competitive restriction. The Spanish Constitution recognizes the freedom of enterprise within the framework of a market economy, therefore any competitive restriction must be justified in some compelling reason of general interest. The regulator can use different instruments so that it must use the least restrictive mechanisms for this.
Finally, some examples of CNMC interventions in the regulation of holiday properties were given:
Madrid:
Article 17.3. Property for tourist use may not be contracted for a period of less than five days and may not be used as a permanent residence, nor may it claim the condition of domicile to prevent the action of the competent inspection.
On the basis of the above arguments, this restriction hinders effective competition, in so far as it restricts the consumer’s choice (by eliminating from the market a certain type of operators which do not exceed those minimum requirements) or raises the costs of operators, which will be reflected in the Price that consumers will have to pay for the Accommodation.
The CNMC acts and positions itself in front of the Administration by filing a Contentious –Administrative appeal against the Decree that regulated the Apartments and Properties for tourist use in the Community of Madrid.
Balearic Islands: Article 52.2. The marketing of the Properties that are in multi-family or townhouse buildings subjected to the horizontal Property regime is prohibited.
The CNMC says that prohibiting the commercialization of Property in multi-family buildings is disproportionate to the general interest that is intended to be protected, so there would be a less restrictive solution.
It is reported on 18 February 2015 to amend the article in question.
Aragon : The decree approved in Aragon specifically excludes from this regulation those Owners or agents who manage two or more Properties in the same building and attributes the regulations on tourist apartments.
The CNMC is of the opinion that the restriction imposed hinders effective competition and therefore the free market, therefore it proposes a modification of the rule.
Canary Islands : Article 3.2. It is expressly excluded from the scope of this Regulation, the buildings located on tourist land that are within the tourist areas or the tourist urbanizations, as well as the Properties located in tourist urbanizations or in mixed residential tourist urbanizations (…).
The CNMC has expressed its opposition to this decree that prohibits the rental between individuals in rural and tourist areas. “They consider it a violation of free competition and unjustifiable barriers to entry into the market” and consider taking the same measure as in Madrid.
In conclusion, the CNMC refers to the benefits of the rental activity of Property by individuals, within the so-called “collaborative economy” since resources are more efficiently allocated, transaction costs and asymmetric Information problems are reduced, and innovation is promoted with incentives to the reduction of Prices and margins. Therefore, holiday properties, and more specifically holiday apartments, need a regulation with the help of the Administration that allows its commercialization.